Atheist Forum

Full Version: Brain-readout of dying atheists
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Hi everybody. With interest I read scientific articles on novel brain readout techniques (like doi:10.1038/nature06713), which I wanted you to read to tell me your opinion about it.

An artifical neural net (multilayer preceptron) could be used as visual encoder to reconstruct the images seen or imagined by an individual from its brain currents (electro-encephalography) or from its biomagnetic fields, alternatively.

Thereby, the images seen or imagined by an volunteer could be reconstructed to a good extent (1 to 5 images per second, black/white, but denoted as "almost youtube-quality").

Another part of the work was the recording of the brain activity of dying persons. More than one hundred volunteers of an elderly hospital were examined in advance and questionnaired for their religious beliefs also. When they were up to die, their brain activity was recorded and the concerning images were reconstructed, finding characteristic sequences, like that reported by near-death-experiencers. There was almost always a tunnel experience, followed by some kind of judgement tribunal chaired by an old man, some kind of life film and afterwards a sequence showing a paradiese garden, or alternatively hellfire, or a "black hole" before brain flatline. Interestingly, hellfire and black hole sequences seemed to be significantly increased for atheist volunteers, whereas the paradiese garden sequences were found more frequently for persons with strong religious believes.

This technique could also be used as lie detector, or at the airport, as detector against terrorism, the inventors of this technique believe.
Don't you think that if it were possible to read peoples minds and project the images on a screen that it would have been all over the media?

This post has been 'lifted' from another forum and I suspect that it will get the same sort of response here.
And assuming it were all true, it wouldn't prove anything except that the dying person is seeing exactly what they expected to see in their last moments of life. It's still not proof of heaven, hell, or the colour of my underwear after a 1 week hiatus from the washing machine.
Surely brain readouts mean the person is still alive, and seeing as we have brought people back from the dead before, you must either go to heaven or hell after actual brain death...
Reference URL's